Story Review Desk

Three archives, side-by-side versions, cleanup actions, and approval tracking.

Approved Stories
All Sources Back to catalog Fairytalez Open source Ririro Open source Grimm CMU Open source
Ririro · Kids Books

Three Guesses

kids-books--three-guesses

Source URL https://ririro.com/kids-books/three-guesses/
Review Status Pending
Original Rule Cleanup Compare Original vs Rule Cleanup

Original

Displayed from body

Once upon a time there was a grandmother who went to spend Thanksgiving day with her children and grandchildren.

She had three grandchildren, Isabel, Jack, and Jamie, and as soon as she had taken off her cloak and bonnet she sat down in Mamma’s big rocking-chair, and called them to her.

“I have a present for each one of you in my brown bag,” she said, “but before I give them to you, you must guess what they are.”

“Oh, Grandma!” said Isabel and Jack and Jamie; and they watched her with wondering eyes as she opened the bag, and took out a bundle.

“Jamie’s present is in this bundle,” said she. “It is red on the outside, and white on the inside and in the middle there is something brown.”

“I believe I know what it is,” said Jack.

“So do I,” said Isabel; but Grandma would not let them guess.

“Jamie must guess it himself,” she said. So Jamie guessed a ball, and a flower and a piece of candy and everything else he could think of; but he could not guess what was in the bundle till Grandma let him smell it. Then he knew.

“An apple, a red apple,” he cried; and when he opened the bundle, there, sure enough, was a big, round apple. It was red on the outside, and white on the inside; and when he had eaten it he found in the middle, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven brown seeds.

The next bundle was for Jack. Grandma shook it up and down, and something rattled inside.

“Marbles,” guessed Jack; but Grandma shook her head.

“Listen to this,” she said:—

“Riddle me, riddle me, what can it be, Hickory, dickory fell from a tree. Run for a hammer, and crickety crack Here are some goodies for little boy Jack.”

“Nuts, nuts!” cried Jack. “Hickory nuts from the big hickory tree that grows in your front yard.” And he was right, too.

“Now it is my turn,” said Isabel; “and I am going to try to guess my present with my very first guess.”

But when Grandma took out a little bundle wrapped in tissue paper, and put it into Isabel’s hands, she was as puzzled as the others had been.

“Be very careful,” said Grandma; “for if you break your present you will never be able to mend it, no matter how hard you try.”

“May I ask questions about it?” asked Isabel.

“Yes,” said Grandma, “you may ask three questions; but when I have answered those I will close my lips, and will not answer another one.”

Then Isabel asked the three questions:—

“What color is my present?”

“White,” said Grandma.

“Where did it come from?”

“The haystack,” said Grandma.

“Who told you it was there?”

“The old white hen,” said Grandma; and she closed her lips just as she had said she would; but Isabel knew what her present was without another word.

“I knew as soon as you said it came from the haystack,” she said. “It is an egg.”

And so it was, a beautiful fresh white egg. Isabel had it for her breakfast the very next morning.

“My!” said Grandma, as the children gathered around her to kiss her and thank her. “What good guessers my grandchildren are!”

Maud Lindsay was an American children's author and kindergarten educator active in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, best known for writing simple, warmly moral stories suited to young listeners. "Three Guesses" reflects her gift for weaving gentle suspense and domestic detail into short narratives designed to be read aloud, making the guessing game feel genuinely exciting for small children.

Raw JSON 
{
  "kind": "story",
  "canonical_url": "https://ririro.com/kids-books/three-guesses/",
  "slug": "three-guesses",
  "story_dirname": "kids-books--three-guesses",
  "section_slug": "kids-books",
  "title": "Three Guesses",
  "author": null,
  "publisher_label": "Ririro",
  "source_version": "unknown",
  "content_type": "chapter_book",
  "language": "en",
  "summary": "\"Three Guesses\" is a charming short story in which a grandmother arrives for Thanksgiving with a brown bag full of surprises — one gift for each of her three grandchildren. Jamie must sniff out his clue, Jack cracks a playful riddle in verse, and Isabel earns only three careful questions before Grandma seals her lips for good. Each child races to name their present before unwrapping it, and the small, homely gifts — an apple, hickory nuts, and a fresh egg — carry all the warmth of the visit.",
  "body": [
    "Once upon a time there was a grandmother who went to spend Thanksgiving day with her children and grandchildren.",
    "She had three grandchildren, Isabel, Jack, and Jamie, and as soon as she had taken off her cloak and bonnet she sat down in Mamma’s big rocking-chair, and called them to her.",
    "“I have a present for each one of you in my brown bag,” she said, “but before I give them to you, you must guess what they are.”",
    "“Oh, Grandma!” said Isabel and Jack and Jamie; and they watched her with wondering eyes as she opened the bag, and took out a bundle.",
    "“Jamie’s present is in this bundle,” said she. “It is red on the outside, and white on the inside and in the middle there is something brown.”",
    "“I believe I know what it is,” said Jack.",
    "“So do I,” said Isabel; but Grandma would not let them guess.",
    "“Jamie must guess it himself,” she said. So Jamie guessed a ball, and a flower and a piece of candy and everything else he could think of; but he could not guess what was in the bundle till Grandma let him smell it. Then he knew.",
    "“An apple, a red apple,” he cried; and when he opened the bundle, there, sure enough, was a big, round apple. It was red on the outside, and white on the inside; and when he had eaten it he found in the middle, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven brown seeds.",
    "The next bundle was for Jack. Grandma shook it up and down, and something rattled inside.",
    "“Marbles,” guessed Jack; but Grandma shook her head.",
    "“Listen to this,” she said:—",
    "“Riddle me, riddle me, what can it be, Hickory, dickory fell from a tree. Run for a hammer, and crickety crack Here are some goodies for little boy Jack.”",
    "“Nuts, nuts!” cried Jack. “Hickory nuts from the big hickory tree that grows in your front yard.” And he was right, too.",
    "“Now it is my turn,” said Isabel; “and I am going to try to guess my present with my very first guess.”",
    "But when Grandma took out a little bundle wrapped in tissue paper, and put it into Isabel’s hands, she was as puzzled as the others had been.",
    "“Be very careful,” said Grandma; “for if you break your present you will never be able to mend it, no matter how hard you try.”",
    "“May I ask questions about it?” asked Isabel.",
    "“Yes,” said Grandma, “you may ask three questions; but when I have answered those I will close my lips, and will not answer another one.”",
    "Then Isabel asked the three questions:—",
    "“What color is my present?”",
    "“White,” said Grandma.",
    "“Where did it come from?”",
    "“The haystack,” said Grandma.",
    "“Who told you it was there?”",
    "“The old white hen,” said Grandma; and she closed her lips just as she had said she would; but Isabel knew what her present was without another word.",
    "“I knew as soon as you said it came from the haystack,” she said. “It is an egg.”",
    "And so it was, a beautiful fresh white egg. Isabel had it for her breakfast the very next morning.",
    "“My!” said Grandma, as the children gathered around her to kiss her and thank her. “What good guessers my grandchildren are!”",
    "Maud Lindsay was an American children's author and kindergarten educator active in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, best known for writing simple, warmly moral stories suited to young listeners. \"Three Guesses\" reflects her gift for weaving gentle suspense and domestic detail into short narratives designed to be read aloud, making the guessing game feel genuinely exciting for small children."
  ],
  "body_text": "Once upon a time there was a grandmother who went to spend Thanksgiving day with her children and grandchildren.\n\nShe had three grandchildren, Isabel, Jack, and Jamie, and as soon as she had taken off her cloak and bonnet she sat down in Mamma’s big rocking-chair, and called them to her.\n\n“I have a present for each one of you in my brown bag,” she said, “but before I give them to you, you must guess what they are.”\n\n“Oh, Grandma!” said Isabel and Jack and Jamie; and they watched her with wondering eyes as she opened the bag, and took out a bundle.\n\n“Jamie’s present is in this bundle,” said she. “It is red on the outside, and white on the inside and in the middle there is something brown.”\n\n“I believe I know what it is,” said Jack.\n\n“So do I,” said Isabel; but Grandma would not let them guess.\n\n“Jamie must guess it himself,” she said. So Jamie guessed a ball, and a flower and a piece of candy and everything else he could think of; but he could not guess what was in the bundle till Grandma let him smell it. Then he knew.\n\n“An apple, a red apple,” he cried; and when he opened the bundle, there, sure enough, was a big, round apple. It was red on the outside, and white on the inside; and when he had eaten it he found in the middle, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven brown seeds.\n\nThe next bundle was for Jack. Grandma shook it up and down, and something rattled inside.\n\n“Marbles,” guessed Jack; but Grandma shook her head.\n\n“Listen to this,” she said:—\n\n“Riddle me, riddle me, what can it be, Hickory, dickory fell from a tree. Run for a hammer, and crickety crack Here are some goodies for little boy Jack.”\n\n“Nuts, nuts!” cried Jack. “Hickory nuts from the big hickory tree that grows in your front yard.” And he was right, too.\n\n“Now it is my turn,” said Isabel; “and I am going to try to guess my present with my very first guess.”\n\nBut when Grandma took out a little bundle wrapped in tissue paper, and put it into Isabel’s hands, she was as puzzled as the others had been.\n\n“Be very careful,” said Grandma; “for if you break your present you will never be able to mend it, no matter how hard you try.”\n\n“May I ask questions about it?” asked Isabel.\n\n“Yes,” said Grandma, “you may ask three questions; but when I have answered those I will close my lips, and will not answer another one.”\n\nThen Isabel asked the three questions:—\n\n“What color is my present?”\n\n“White,” said Grandma.\n\n“Where did it come from?”\n\n“The haystack,” said Grandma.\n\n“Who told you it was there?”\n\n“The old white hen,” said Grandma; and she closed her lips just as she had said she would; but Isabel knew what her present was without another word.\n\n“I knew as soon as you said it came from the haystack,” she said. “It is an egg.”\n\nAnd so it was, a beautiful fresh white egg. Isabel had it for her breakfast the very next morning.\n\n“My!” said Grandma, as the children gathered around her to kiss her and thank her. “What good guessers my grandchildren are!”\n\nMaud Lindsay was an American children's author and kindergarten educator active in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, best known for writing simple, warmly moral stories suited to young listeners. \"Three Guesses\" reflects her gift for weaving gentle suspense and domestic detail into short narratives designed to be read aloud, making the guessing game feel genuinely exciting for small children.",
  "theme_slugs": [],
  "listing_memberships": [
    {
      "type": "author",
      "slug": "maud-lindsay",
      "title": "Maud Lindsay",
      "url": "https://ririro.com/author/maud-lindsay/"
    }
  ],
  "reading_meta": {
    "reading_level": null,
    "age_band": null,
    "read_time": null
  },
  "media": {
    "has_audio": false,
    "has_pdf": true,
    "has_images": true
  },
  "asset_refs": {
    "pdf_urls": [
      "https://ririro.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Three-Guesses_compressed.pdf"
    ],
    "audio_urls": [],
    "image_urls": [
      "https://ririro.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/three-guesses.png",
      "https://ririro.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/three-guesses-2.png"
    ]
  },
  "breadcrumbs": [
    "Three Guesses"
  ],
  "scraped_at": "2026-05-07T12:53:42+00:00"
}